shanta
Jan 15 2005, 11:48 PM
| QUOTE (Sue Darlow @ Jan 15 2005, 09:51 AM) |
| QUOTE (arnab @ Jan 15 2005, 11:09 PM) | | i think kokam (if this is the same thing that shows up in recipes as kokum--a dried flower of some sort) is used more widely in west coast cooking. my penguin kerala cookbook lists it as a viable alternative to cambodge as a souring agent. |
According to Monisha Bharadwaj in The Indian Pantry, kokum is Garcinia indica, native to India,and without an English equivalent. Used in the cooking of Gujarat, Maharashtra and the south. Much used in Malvani cooking. Has the ability to counteract heat, hence made into drinks a lot. The fruit is purple when ripe. The five to eight seeds are removed and the rind removed. When dired it is dark purple to black. Used as a souring agent. Roshna, I remember those delicious dals at your place, complete with kokums floating around... Sue |
Kokum aka. "Birund" is
Mangosteen. (Ha! I beat gingerly!!

)
The dried kokum used as a souring agent is called 'amsool' in Konkani and is widely used in the Western Coastal Indian cuisine, not sure about other regions, though.
Kokum syrup(scroll down) is also available, which can be used as a lemonade or a
Kokum Fizz(scroll to the bottom).
Sue Darlow
Jan 16 2005, 12:06 AM
I am not too convinced, as mangosteen is called
Garcinia mangostana in Latin and the interior pulp is white, not purple or black...I have seen and eaten mangosteens in SE Asia, but not in India. Perhaps they are cousin brothers?
Sue
Pratibha
Jan 16 2005, 01:53 AM
Kokum/Kokam is called Aamsul in Marathi. Aamsul surbat (cold drink like lemonade) if used to fight heat in summer. It is incredubly thirst quenching.
Pictuere.According to
this it is called Garcinia Indica.
Most famous food made from kokum/aamsul/aamsol is SoLachi KaDhi - short for Aamsolachi kadDhi.
Pratibha
gingerly
Jan 16 2005, 10:14 AM

tut-tut shanta!
this is the beauteous mangosteen.but they are surely relatiews Sue,and do grow in india-
| QUOTE |
| The tree was planted in Ceylon about 1800 and in India in 1881. There it succeeds in 4 limited areas–the Nilgiri Hills, the Tinnevelly district of southern Madras, the Kanya-kumani district at the southernmost tip of the Madras peninsula, and in Kerala State in southwestern India. |
i got my first taste of them at a fruit research station in the nilgiris.they also sold 'bumblimaas'(pomelo) and 'gowah' jelly
ajit
Jan 16 2005, 10:30 AM
kokum, aamsul etc. is 'fish tamarind'.
It's used in Malayali cuisine as well. Sorry Roshna.
gingerly
Jan 16 2005, 01:06 PM
| QUOTE (ajit @ Jan 16 2005, 10:30 AM) |
kokum, aamsul etc. is 'fish tamarind'. It's used in Malayali cuisine as well. Sorry Roshna. |
fish tamarind' in kerala can be
anther cousinbrother ..
bague25
Jan 16 2005, 04:39 PM
| QUOTE (Pratibha @ Jan 15 2005, 10:23 PM) |
Kokum/Kokam is called Aamsul in Marathi. Aamsul surbat (cold drink like lemonade) if used to fight heat in summer. It is incredubly thirst quenching.
Pictuere. According to this it is called Garcinia Indica.
Most famous food made from kokum/aamsul/aamsol is SoLachi KaDhi - short for Aamsolachi kadDhi.
Pratibha |
Pratibhatai
The Fanaspapad in the link (look into jackfruit products) made me drool all over my keyboard...
I have to investigate if they ship
Thanks for this trip...
Bague
ajit
Jan 16 2005, 09:49 PM
| QUOTE |
| fish tamarind' in kerala can be anther cousinbrother .. |
Gingerly, why do you think this is not the same as amsul/kokum ?
Pratibha
Jan 16 2005, 10:40 PM
Check this out. Garcinia cambogia for weight loss, gotta try it.
| QUOTE |
| Garcinia cambogia is the fruit of the garcinia indica tree also known as Brindleberry, grown in southern India. Hydroxycitric acid (HCA), the active ingredient of garcinia cambogia, is synthesized from the rind of the cambogia fruit. |
Hey bague, you are welcome, but who ya callin' Tai?
Pratibha
shanta
Jan 17 2005, 12:05 AM
| QUOTE (gingerly @ Jan 15 2005, 08:44 PM) |
i got my first taste of them at a fruit research station in the nilgiris.they also sold 'bumblimaas'(pomelo) and 'gowah' jelly  |
Is it used in Tamil cuisine? Hubby remembers fresh mangosteens in Madras.
gingerly
Jan 17 2005, 02:42 AM
| QUOTE (ajit @ Jan 16 2005, 09:49 PM) |
| QUOTE | | fish tamarind' in kerala can be anther cousinbrother .. |
Gingerly, why do you think this is not the same as amsul/kokum ?
|
ajit-the penguin kerala cookbook lists both kokum(garcinia indica/punampuli) and cambodge(garcinia gummigutta/kudampuli) as souring agents used in cooking with the latter indicated as being quite distinct from the kokum used elsewhere.
after an earlier discussion,i did some poking about and came up with
this picture of the kudampuli fruit.i later got a look at some kudampuli.the ridged peel separates like petals so i guess that's why the recipes call for a few 'petals ' of cambodge.still not clear myself if it's gummigutta or cambogia.
from the link above-
| QUOTE |
| Dried fruits of Garcinia cambogia, also called Malabar tamarind, are widely used as a spice in the preparation of fish curry in southern India. |
| QUOTE |
| Taxonomic difficulties encountered during studies on the trees of Bombay are discussed, with specific reference to 3 species of Clusiaceae from Maharashtra: Calophyllum calaba (now given the name C. apetalum for Indian species, with C. calaba retained for the Sri Lankan species), Cambogia gummi-gutta (now given the name Garcinia cambogia), and Garcinia morella (now given the name G. gummi-gutta). |
shanta-i haven't come across kokum or references to it in tamil cuisine but that means little.i'm sure where that where it is available,it will eventually work it's way into the repertoire!i wonder how much of the mangosteen available in india is locally grown and masquerading as 'imported' (and therefore even more exorbitantly priced)i gather kiwi fruit is now being grown in himachal !
bague25
Jan 17 2005, 12:49 PM
| QUOTE (Pratibha @ Jan 16 2005, 07:10 PM) |
Check this out. Garcinia cambogia for weight loss, gotta try it.
| QUOTE | | Garcinia cambogia is the fruit of the garcinia indica tree also known as Brindleberry, grown in southern India. Hydroxycitric acid (HCA), the active ingredient of garcinia cambogia, is synthesized from the rind of the cambogia fruit. |
Hey bague, you are welcome, but who ya callin' Tai?
Pratibha
|
Sorry Did not mean to upset you, Pratibha...
gingerly
Jan 18 2005, 12:03 PM
is anyone familiar with 'thekera' as applied in assamese cooking?it seems to kokum or another relative-
recipeshttp://rubymurray.com/curry/DisplayRecipe....ia+Maasor+Tenga
shanta
Jan 18 2005, 12:28 PM
Looks like it is a cousin of kokum:
http://www.aaranyak.org/Gibbon.htm| QUOTE |
Floral Composition 8 Garcinia species(Thekera) |
seajay
Jan 18 2005, 09:39 PM
from gingerly's "recipe" link -- a fraction of its pomo ingredient list (line breaks as original):
| QUOTE |
One onion (big) Eggplant 5 small broccoli 1 small head potato 4 parboiled onion 1 large, slices lengthwise oil vegetable cooking only
|
Mostly curious about line 3

though the last is probably the most po(mo)etic -- or would that be Language Poetry?
(just a little plebian joking all ye bards)
cj
gingerly
Jan 19 2005, 12:10 AM
part of a post that got me wondering if it was the same-
| QUOTE |
When I was ready with strainer in hand, I discovered that my 'tamarind' was actually thekera. I had a little cache of dark brown patties of both thekera and teteli and obviously picked the wrong one that day. |
-dark brown like tamarind(teteli).
from outlook traveller-
| QUOTE |
| A breakfast staple for the farmer is often poita bhat which is rice cooked the previous day and soaked overnight in water. Some add a few slices of thekera (Garcinia cowa roxa) for faster fermentation |
and on-
| QUOTE |
13. Garcinia cowa Roxburgh, Fl. Ind. 2: 622. 1832.
yun shu
Garcinia roxburghii Wight; G. wallichii Choisy; Oxycarpus gangetica Buchanan-Hamilton.
Trees, 8--12 m tall, 15--20 cm in diam. Bark dark brown. Branches many, slender, aggregated on top of trunk, horizontal but usually distally pendulous; branchlets dark brown, striate. Petioles 0.8--1.5(--2) cm; leaf blades lanceolate or oblong-lanceolate, 6-14 X 2--5 cm, papery, base cuneate, sometimes slightly decurrent, apex acuminate or long-acuminate, rarely acute or obtuse; midvein elevated abaxially, impressed adaxially; lateral veins 12--18 pairs; tertiary veins conspicuous on both surfaces. Flowers dioecious. Male flowers 3--8, terminal or axillary, in an umbel; umbel shortly pedunculate or rarely sessile, 4-bracteate at base; bracts subulate; pedicels slender, 4--8 mm; petals yellow, ca. 2 X as long as sepals; stamen fascicles 4, connate, forming a central capitate 4-sided mass of ca. 40-50 anthers; free filaments absent or sometimes a few, short; pistillode absent. Female flowers usually solitary, axillary, larger than male ones; pedicels robust, 2--3 mm; staminodes united in lower half and enveloping ovary base; filaments long or short, usually shorter than ovary; ovary ovoid, 4--8-celled; stigma radiately lobed, papillate, 6--7 mm high, 4--8-angular outside. Mature fruit opaquely yellow-brown, ovoid, 4--5 cm in diam., 4--8-sulcate outside, oblique, usually apiculate. Seeds 2--4, narrow, fusiform, slightly curved, ca. 2.5 cm, rough. Fl. May, fr. Jul-Oct. 2n = 52.
Humid mixed forests on hills or in valleys; (100--)400--900(--1300) m. S and W Yunnan [E Bangladesh, India, "Indochina" [list specific countries??], Malaysia]. |
gingerly
May 31 2006, 05:24 AM
i have some 'kokum phool'-hard,dry half-sections of kokum fruit,with the seeds left in.it seems to function much like the fleshier version but with less fruitiness.does anyone know if there are specific uses for this kind of kokum?
Nichiro
May 31 2006, 06:09 AM
QUOTE(gingerly @ May 31 2006, 05:24 AM)

i have some 'kokum phool'-hard,dry half-sections of kokum fruit,with the seeds left in.it seems to function much like the fleshier version but with less fruitiness.does anyone know if there are specific uses for this kind of kokum?
Yes, You can use them in preparing Gujarati Dal. Most of Gujaratis use Kokum. They are used as souring agent.
arnab
May 31 2006, 06:14 AM
gingerly, this dried, semi-hard kokum is the only kind i've ever bought in the u.s. i've been using it merrily in my kerala recipes (subbing for cambodge) never realizing there was a more optimal kind.
Nichiro
May 31 2006, 06:40 AM
Gingerly,
You can use it as diet control , weight reducing agent.
gingerly
May 31 2006, 08:30 AM
unfortunately,i'm all out of the soft version-maybe someone who has some can post a pic?they taste very similar,though the dried version is a little smoky.also,i can't imagine sol kadi would taste quite right made from the dried stuff.
Nichiro,i’ll pretend i didn’t read that last post.
Wildflower
May 31 2006, 10:33 PM
Dunno why I haven't paid attention to this thread before. Really took me back to the good ole days. In Delhi you didn't get kokum in regular grocery/kirana stores. You could get the good soft, moist, stain your mouth blackish purple stuff at the Maharashtra Emporium on Baba Kharag Singh Marg. I used to just eat it right out of the bag like khatta aam papad. Mmmm. Have some in my fridge but I can't remember the last time I cooked with it, I still eat it plain.
gingerly
May 31 2006, 11:02 PM
pictures of the soft peel version.
another(from one hot stove) showing the fine crystals that sometimes precipitate out of the peel.
arnab
Jun 21 2006, 04:47 AM
achcha, as i mentioned recently, thanks to veena, i now have a lot of very fragrant fresh, moist kokum. considering i only have one recipe in my regular rotation that calls for kokum (as a sub for cambodge in the nadan meen kari from the penguin kerala cookbook) i am worried that i may not use it all to best benefit. so please to give suggestions.
a recipe for solachi kadi anyone?
Veena
Jun 21 2006, 05:39 AM
You can use it in daals instead of other souring agents (Nichiro's tuvar-ni-daal uses it). I also toss in a few along with vegetables while making regular simple dry sabzis. It gives a subtly different sour flavour compared to tamarind or amchur.
Here's how we make sol-kadi at home: soak a few (six to seven pieces) in a cup or so of water. Keep aside while you attend to other matters. After the kokum has done its work in the water, add freshly extracted coconut milk, and salt. Proportion of water to coconut milk can very depending on how thick or thin you like it. You can jazz it up with a tadka of mustard and curry leaves, and coriander leaves; but some prefer solkadi without such intrusions. An alternative preparation is to use thin buttermilk instead of coconut milk.
Perhaps someone can provide a recipe for kokum sherbet.
Veena
RedPepper
Jun 21 2006, 07:55 PM
For Kerala style fish curry, kodampuli is used(not kokum). In some parts of Kerala, tamarind is used as well.
Kokum and kodampuli are different.
arnab
Jun 21 2006, 08:17 PM
is kodampuli cambodge? vijayan suggests kokum as a substitute. of late, given the quality of kokum available here, i'd been using tamarind. can anyone speak to the taste difference between cambodge and kokum?
gingerly
Jun 22 2006, 12:13 AM
there are some recipes in the upper crust link(post#23) though i think they're throwing the kokum about far too liberally.must think it grows on trees or something.
kodampuli has a cleaner flavour to it-sort of citrus to kokum's plum.
gingerly
Aug 18 2006, 10:13 PM
Veena
Mar 2 2008, 10:58 PM
This is a souring agent that I picked up from a rural arts and crafts exhibition in Goa. The woman who was selling it belonged to one of the several self-help groups for women that are found in Goan villages. She said it was used instead of kokum, but unlike kokum, it was ground along with the coconut masala. My father, who is from South Canara, recognized them as
onTi sola.n or
vonTi sola (sola.n is the Konkani term for edible peels or skin). They had a tree in his childhood home and the delicate fruit had to be collected before it hit the ground (else it would be squished). It was then chopped up, sun-dried for a couple of days, salted and then stored to be used in masala for curries. Supposed to be especially delicious in fish curries. We had it in egg curry today - it is milder than tamarind and kokum. It also tasted very good by itself (if one's taste leans towards eating imli and kairi as solo delicacies). Anyone here recognises it or knows the English or botanical name for this fruit?

Veena
gingerly
Mar 3 2008, 02:42 AM
Veena, could you ask your father if he recalls the colour of the ripe fruit?
pocahontas123
Mar 3 2008, 12:23 PM
bague25
Mar 3 2008, 01:46 PM
Veena
Are these a bit sweetish? I have a vague memory of having seen/eaten this, but it's really too far back to remember anything

...
Wildflower
Mar 3 2008, 02:12 PM
QUOTE(Veena @ Mar 2 2008, 09:28 AM)

She said it was used instead of kokum, but unlike kokum, it was ground along with the coconut masala. My father, who is from South Canara, recognized them as
onTi sola.n or
vonTi sola (sola.n is the Konkani term for edible peels or skin). They had a tree in his childhood home and the delicate fruit had to be collected before it hit the ground (else it would be squished). It was then chopped up, sun-dried for a couple of days, salted and then stored to be used in masala for curries. Supposed to be especially delicious in fish curries. We had it in egg curry today - it is milder than tamarind and kokum. It also tasted very good by itself (if one's taste leans towards eating imli and kairi as solo delicacies). Anyone here recognises it or knows the English or botanical name for this fruit?

Doesn't it (oddly enough) it look a lot like the cross sections in this
photo? [Mahanandi calls it kokum, but it is not the lovely moist purple peel form.]
hibiscus
Mar 3 2008, 02:48 PM
QUOTE(Veena @ Mar 3 2008, 01:28 AM)

This is a souring agent that I picked up from a rural arts and crafts exhibition in Goa. The woman who was selling it belonged to one of the several self-help groups for women that are found in Goan villages. She said it was used instead of kokum, but unlike kokum, it was ground along with the coconut masala. My father, who is from South Canara, recognized them as onTi sola.n or vonTi sola (sola.n is the Konkani term for edible peels or skin).
Ye olde vottambe/vottambi sol aka jarigeda votte, perhaps?
gingerly
Mar 4 2008, 02:37 AM
that's what i was thinking, hibi, but something suggested jackfruit, so i wonder if it's something like
lakoocha.
possibly?
QUOTE
"It's sour, excellent for sambars and curried vegetables and is made from 'vatehuli'. Vatehuli is artocarpus lakoocha, a valuable multi-purpose tree native to tropical India, used for fruit, furniture, timber and feed.
wilde, some
sickly specimens to look at.
Wildflower
Mar 4 2008, 02:50 AM
QUOTE(gingerly @ Mar 3 2008, 01:07 PM)

wilde, some
sickly specimens to look at.
Figure 3 and 11 and my memory make it seem a not implausible hypothesis.
On the souring agent I'm holding out till Veena tells us if her father remembers about color etc.
Ammini
Mar 4 2008, 03:26 AM
Veena:
My Kerala Christian friends use a souring agent called
Kodumpuli in their fish curries. I have read that in Goa also it is used in fish curries.
Wikipedia lists
Kokum as Garcinia indica. Perhaps these two are of the same family?
Wildflower
Mar 4 2008, 04:13 AM
QUOTE(Ammini @ Mar 3 2008, 01:56 PM)

Veena:
My Kerala Christian friends use a souring agent called
Kodumpuli in their fish curries. I have read that in Goa also it is used in fish curries.
Wikipedia lists
Kokum as Garcinia indica. Perhaps these two are of the same famil.?
Ammini they are Garcina cambogia (kudampuli) and Garcinia indica (kokum). The problem might be that both fruits can be preserved in more than one way. What I have at home is the moist, purplish, salt preserved kind. See
moist purple kokum and
moist purple kudampuli. For kerala fish curry recipes using this moist kind of kudampuli see recipes in
this blog.
However, the fruit might also be cut into cross sections and dried -- like
this (and the Mahanandi photo I linked upthread).
jason gogal
Mar 4 2008, 07:24 AM
QUOTE(Wildflower @ Mar 3 2008, 04:43 PM)

Ammini they are Garcina cambogia (kudampuli) and Garcinia indica (kokum). The problem might be that both fruits can be preserved in more than one way. What I have at home is the moist, purplish, salt preserved kind. See
moist purple kokum and
moist purple kudampuli. For kerala fish curry recipes using this moist kind of kudampuli see recipes in
this blog.
However, the fruit might also be cut into cross sections and dried -- like
this (and the Mahanandi photo I linked upthread).
Interesting stuff! Thanks Wildflower.
Ammini
Mar 4 2008, 07:47 AM
Wildflower: Thanks. I knew you would have the answer. Kudampuli is not generally used in Kerala vegetarian cooking and I have never used it. And I know nothing about fish cookery.
gingerly
Mar 4 2008, 08:48 AM
there's a pic of fresh kudampuli upthread.
Wildflower
Mar 4 2008, 09:00 AM
QUOTE(gingerly @ Mar 3 2008, 07:18 PM)

there's a pic of fresh kudampuli upthread.
Yep, I was deeply envious at the time.
QUOTE(gingerly @ Aug 18 2006, 08:43 AM)

I always meant to ask -- did you try to cook with it? What was it like when you bit into the fresh fruit?
gingerly
Mar 4 2008, 09:09 AM
QUOTE(Wildflower @ Mar 4 2008, 09:00 AM)

What was it like when you bit into the fresh fruit?
um..
not pretty. it's like extreme carambola. leaves the throat very raw, as does the dried version-unlike kokum. i didn't cook anything, unfortunately.
(bumped up hoping Veena's dad can take a look at the thread and id.)
loislane
Mar 4 2008, 10:00 AM
One of my favorite things as a child (and I didn't have too many favorite things then) were these fresh kokums preserved in salt and sugar that my babysitter used to make. Sweet-sour and perfect, I always raided the jar at her place. When I was in India last year I made it a quest to find out if she still makes them, and she doesn't, because she doesn't get fresh kokums from whoever she used to get it from in the decades past. I am very sad that I might never get to relish them again. :-(
Wildflower
Mar 4 2008, 10:04 AM
QUOTE(gingerly @ Mar 3 2008, 07:39 PM)

QUOTE(Wildflower @ Mar 4 2008, 09:00 AM)

What was it like when you bit into the fresh fruit?
um..
not pretty. it's like extreme carambola. leaves the throat very raw, as does the dried version-unlike kokum. i didn't cook anything, unfortunately.
(bumped up hoping Veena's dad can take a look at the thread and id.)
Yep, I keep pausing over the description of the fruit as delicate.
QUOTE(Veena @ Mar 2 2008, 09:28 AM)

They had a tree in his childhood home and the delicate fruit had to be collected before it hit the ground (else it would be squished).
Semi-ripe G. cambogia are not very delicate, but perhaps very ripe ones are squishy; or very likely it is something else entirely.
Veena
Mar 6 2008, 08:09 AM
Gingerly, WF: my father's further input will have to wait until I return to Bombay in about a couple of weeks.
Veena
Jenni
Mar 8 2008, 12:42 AM
Wow, didn't realise there was a whole thread about kokum, what a coincidence, just used some tonight! I often use it in dals, and also coconut milk dishes. I find it has a really subtle yet very enhancing taste. Seems to keep forever in the fridge too! I have a great big bag of softish dried stuff in there.
ajit
Mar 8 2008, 12:51 AM
QUOTE(Veena @ Jun 20 2006, 04:09 PM)

Here's how we make sol-kadi at home: soak a few (six to seven pieces) in a cup or so of water. Keep aside while you attend to other matters. After the kokum has done its work in the water, add freshly extracted coconut milk, and salt. Proportion of water to coconut milk can very depending on how thick or thin you like it. You can jazz it up with a tadka of mustard and curry leaves, and coriander leaves; but some prefer solkadi without such intrusions. An alternative preparation is to use thin buttermilk instead of coconut milk.
In keeping with the custom in my mother's kitchen I add flakes of garlic and green chillies to spice things up.
Veena
Mar 9 2008, 09:32 PM
QUOTE(ajit @ Mar 8 2008, 12:51 AM)

in my mother's kitchen I add flakes of garlic and green chillies to spice things up.
There is a variation to the sol-kadi, which involves adding garlic and green chillies to the coconut while grinding it for the coconut milk. This is called lasNaachi-kadi.
Addition to my earlier post: a cup of water might be too much for 6-7 skins of kokum. It should be more like 5-6 tablespoons of water, especially if you are going to eat it with rice. For a mild drink, a cup would probably be okay.
Veena
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please
click here.